There are many ways to be picky; a distinction clearly made by this week’s guest writer. Dan is the original picky eater in my family. Ever since we were children, whereas I shovelled anything and everything down my throat – often to the detriment of my own health and wellbeing, because that was what good children did -- Dan was clear about what he would and wouldn’t put into his mouth. What I find so admirable about his eating habits is that these days, he is not beyond trying new things. So respect to my little brother for teaching me all those years ago that just because it’s on your plate doesn’t mean you have to eat it, no matter what anyone says.
With love,
Gabriela
Hello. My name is Dan and I’m a picky eater. Unlike a picky foodie, a picky eater can in fact eat anything. Only, the picky eater would rather not have to.
I have been picky all my life and will probably remain picky forever. Odd-shaped fruits, exotic spices, pureed anything, raisins.
Like many children I was allergic to vegetables. I was at war with a food group and became an expert at covert operations. My speciality: extreme rendition. An empty juice carton might secretly transport a busload of Brussels sprouts on its way to the bin. A spoon, so innocent on a plate, could be hiding a mushroom. (Yes, mushrooms, I know.)
Later, perhaps unsurprisingly, this changed. Today I eat a variety of foods. Or rather, I am prepared to try new things. If they take my fancy, I might come back for seconds. But I might not. For being picky is not something you get rid of only by expanding your horizons. Just because I tried that Christmas pudding doesn’t mean I’ve converted.
You see, there is a science behind picky eating. A picky eater will go through several stages before that grub will pass their lips.
First: risk assessment – will that cauliflower kill me?
Secondly, what I call “the disclaimer” – accepting the possibility that what you are about to try might be horrible after all. Sometimes it’s not all in your head. (The disclaimer is with the food. You don’t owe it (or the chef) anything; you reserve the right not to finish what’s on your plate.)
And finally, the third and perhaps most important stage: “the contract”. Similar to the disclaimer, the contract is about the conversation you have with yourself about the meal in front of you. Different to the disclaimer though, the contract deals with the prospect of the picky eater actually enjoying what they assumed they wouldn’t.
Often, I find the hardest part about being a picky eater the moment you realise that what you’ve been avoiding for so long – because it once tasted disgusting or because it literally looks like shit – is in fact quite tasty.
Apart from having to acknowledge that you would have enjoyed all the previous moments of near misses – the picky “what-ifs” – there is the much deeper problem of having to incorporate new delicious fare into what is a carefully honed, almost mathematically precise picky eater menu.
Take the tomato for example. These fruits (!) were never much of a problem for me. In a salad, in a dish – I either didn’t notice them or I could just push them aside. Unless they’re on a pizza or in a sauce, they didn’t taste much like anything to me. Then one day I woke up and thought, you know what, to hell with tomatoes. In sandwiches especially, they just sit there, awkwardly sliced, flavourless, ready to burst and land on your shirt.
At the sandwich place near where I work I’m known as the “no tomato guy.” They’ve stopped asking, they just know. Until one day, when one of the specials included a slice of the bastards. I thought to myself, they know it’s me, so no point in saying anything. Yet when I looked at the tabletop behind the counter, there it was, sitting at the summit of my lunch, about to be covered by a bun.
Wait! I said. What, they said. Tomato, I said, pointing. But it’s slow-roasted, they said. And they said it in an almost whiny, frustrated tone, like I was wasting their time. I wanted to say to them, it’s me, the no-tomato-guy, remember? But I could see in their eyes that it was different this time. Slow-roasted really meant something, and it was something I was going to have to try.
When I returned a couple of days later, they remarked that I was still alive. Humbled, I bowed my head a bit and told them what they wanted to hear. They knew that I wasn’t about to embark on some ridiculous Texas-portioned tomato-fest, but they also knew that the goal posts had shifted.
And that right there is the difficulty of the picky eater contract. The way you approach food – rehearsed and with precedent – can be changed. To do that can require a whole lot of nerve, if only because you have to convince the toughest judge of all: yourself.



Comments